eMudhra intermediate CA keys found weak; browsers block eight certificates
Software that depends on web PKI but cannot filter intermediates stays exposed until its updates arrive.
Private keys for eight eMudhra intermediate certificate authority certificates were compromised because they were generated with almost no randomness, so their values could be enumerated and anyone holding the matching keys could forge certificates. Six were TLS certificates trusted by the Apple, Chrome, Microsoft and Mozilla root programs, and two were codesigning certificates trusted by Microsoft. Browsers blocked the affected intermediates through their revocation blocklists, but many other software packages that rely on web PKI lack any way to filter intermediates, and some projects have removed the emSign ECC Root CA - G3, which breaks legitimate certificates chained to it. Developers relying on bundled or system root stores, or on mutual TLS authentication built on web PKI roots, remain exposed until their updates reach them. eMudhra has since announced that it is withdrawing from the global SSL/TLS business, citing costs and compliance demands while that line generates about 1 percent of its revenue.
Why it matters
Browsers could block the affected intermediates through their revocation blocklists, but many other packages that rely on web PKI have no way to filter intermediates. Some projects removed the emSign ECC Root CA - G3, which also breaks legitimate certificates chained to it, while mutual TLS deployments that trust web PKI roots remain open to forged client certificates. The episode also shows how a weak key generation process at one certificate authority can reach far beyond its own customers, and eMudhra has since said it is leaving the global SSL/TLS business.
Series eMudhra weak intermediate keys
- Microsoft removes trust in eMudhra certificates after weak CA keys found
- eMudhra intermediate CA keys found weak; browsers block eight certificates
- Eight eMudhra intermediate certificates blocked by browsers after weak keys found
Matters or hype?
Does this story matter, or is it hype? Vote before you see what everyone else said.