Epic Games asks Supreme Court to uphold contempt finding against Apple over iPhone payments
The justices will decide whether Apple's 27% commission on web purchases breached the injunction, a question that bears directly on how app payments are handled.
Epic Games has asked the US Supreme Court to uphold a contempt finding against Apple, arguing Apple defied a lower court injunction on iPhone app payments. Epic says Apple imposed a 27% commission on purchases made through the open web and made external payment links hard to find and use, which it calls a deliberate evasion of the order. The Ninth Circuit upheld the contempt ruling, and the district court reportedly described Apple's supporting report as a sham. Apple counters that contempt requires no fair ground of doubt about a violation, that the injunction never mentioned commissions, and that Epic conceded the order did not explicitly bar such a fee. Apple says it strongly disagrees with the findings and has invested heavily in compliance, so the Supreme Court will now decide whether the contempt finding stands.
Why it matters
The case turns on whether Apple's commission and link restrictions defied a lower court order that did not mention commissions. If the Supreme Court leaves the contempt finding standing, it would confirm that a company can be held in contempt for conduct its injunction did not expressly prohibit. If it is overturned, the ruling would signal that such orders must spell out the specific fees and behaviour they cover. Either outcome shapes how far courts can go in enforcing app-store payment rules against platform owners.
Matters or hype?
Does this story matter, or is it hype? Vote before you see what everyone else said.