Judge dismisses Chegg and Penske antitrust suits over Google AI search
The ruling leaves Google’s AI search features standing, while publishers cannot claim expected traffic as a legal right.
A US federal judge has thrown out antitrust suits from Chegg and Penske Media that tried to hold Google liable for traffic losses tied to AI search features, finding that Google’s conduct is not unlawful under antitrust law. The cases, filed in 2025, argued that AI Overviews and related systems let Google reuse publishers’ material for AI answers while sending less search traffic back to sites. Judge Amit Mehta rejected the idea that publishers’ expectations of referral traffic amount to a legal agreement with Google. Separately, Google is said to be running a pilot with roughly 100 publishers that pays them based on how much their material contributes to AI Overviews, AI Mode, and Gemini responses, with one participant reportedly making more than $1 million in a year.
Why it matters
For publishers, the decision narrows one legal path for challenging AI search features that reuse their material and reduce referrals. It also leaves room for Google’s publisher payout pilot to develop as a separate commercial track, rather than a court-ordered fix.
Matters or hype?
Does this story matter, or is it hype? Vote before you see what everyone else said.